LED Lighting and Controls for Business: Which Upgrades Save Most
Updated 23 October 2026 · Renewable Energy for Businesses
Want to cut what your site uses and pays for energy?
Request a quoteWhich lighting upgrades save most?
The sources give ranges, not a league table, and each range has conditions attached. The table sets out what each one says and where it comes from.
| Upgrade | Saving stated | Source | Condition |
|---|---|---|---|
| LED in place of older lighting | Up to 80 per cent of cost; 70 per cent of energy against older fluorescent | Energy Technology List (government, page undated) | Depends on what is replaced and how long it runs |
| Occupancy sensors | About 30 per cent of electricity | CIBSE Top Tips 2 (undated) | Rooms that are often empty |
| Daylight sensors | Up to 40 per cent of electricity | CIBSE Top Tips 2 | Rooms with natural light |
| Automatic controls in general | 30 to 50 per cent | Energy Technology List; Carbon Trust (5 December 2011) | Where automatic controls are used |
| LED with occupancy sensing, daylight dimming and scheduling | 50 to 80 per cent of lighting energy | CIBSE Journal (January 2026) | A full retrofit; also reduces internal heat gains |
| Time switches | No figure in the sources checked | Energy Technology List | Places with fixed operating hours, such as a shop or restaurant |
The ranges overlap because they start from different baselines. Fitting LED first leaves less for controls to save, so do not add the rows together.
On payback, GOV.UK's business advice says that upgrading to LED bulbs could deliver significant cost savings, on average in under 3 years, in a passage comparing LED with halogen bulbs. That is an average across upgrades, and the same page of advice does not say how it was calculated. Payback follows running hours, as the worked example below shows.
A practical order, by hours rather than by any official ranking, is to switch off what is not needed, change the circuits that run longest to LED, add presence detection where rooms sit empty, and add daylight dimming where there is daylight to use. The guide to cutting business energy costs shows where lighting sits among other measures.
Should you retrofit LED lamps or fit new luminaires?
The government's Energy Technology List (ETL) draws a line between the two. Its lighting guidance note, dated 17 April 2024, says only complete lighting units can meet ETL criteria because products have to be tested as an integrated whole. It says retrofit LED lamps and retrofit T5 adapters are re-lamping technologies and do not meet the criteria, and that an LED lamp combined with a luminaire and control gear designed for a linear fluorescent lamp would not be a permissible ETL solution.
That does not make a lamp swap wrong. It means the two products are assessed differently, so ask each quote which one it is. Useful questions:
- Is the product an ETL-listed Efficient White Lighting Unit? The ETL says a product must be specifically listed to be ETL compliant in this category.
- Does the work keep the existing control gear, or remove it?
- What light level will result at the working plane, and how was it checked?
- How are the emergency lighting and its testing handled?
Supply is also shifting. Defra's page on RoHS exemption decisions lists the mercury exemptions for normal-lifetime tri-band T5, T8 and T12 linear fluorescent lamps as revoked, expiring on 1 February 2024. It does not say what that means for lamps already installed, so ask a supplier about future availability before planning a tube-by-tube approach. On power factor, CIBSE Journal says LED lamps normally have it corrected locally within the luminaire, so reactive power charges, covered in the power factor guide, are rarely the worry here.
What suits warehouses and other high-bay buildings?
The Carbon Trust's warehousing guide (February 2019) says significant savings can be achieved by optimising lighting, and that low and no cost savings come easily from better controls and night-time and weekend shut-down routines. Where aisles and stock areas are occupied only in bursts, presence detection is the control aimed at that pattern. The ETL says controls should be chosen to suit the type of space and whether it is day-lit or intermittently occupied.
Two cautions apply. First, the ETL notes that where safety is very important, dimming is used rather than switching off after a sensor stops detecting movement. Second, CIBSE says lighting with automatic control should include a fail-safe so that no occupied area is plunged into darkness if the control fails, plus a manual override. The ETL adds that LED lighting designed for warehouses and factories must have a colour rendering index of at least Ra 80 to meet its criteria.
For example, take a 2,000 square metre warehouse where 100 high-bay fittings of 250 W are replaced by fittings of 120 W. These wattages are assumptions for illustration, not sourced figures. The reduction is 13 kW. Over 6,000 hours a year that is 78,000 kWh, and over 3,000 hours it is 39,000 kWh. Halving the hours halves the saving and doubles the payback, which is why the site's own running hours matter more than any quoted percentage.
Which controls suit which space?
The ETL covers five kinds of lighting control, installed singly or in combination:
- Time controllers switch lighting off at set times and suit places with fixed operating hours.
- Presence detectors monitor occupancy and switch off or dim lighting when it is not needed.
- Daylight detectors with switching turn lighting off when daylight is sufficient.
- Daylight detectors with dimming adjust output instead of switching.
- Central control units manage the whole installation, including some or all of the types above.
The ETL calls lighting controls an unlisted technology, because there are too many product combinations for a list. It says the supplier should give the customer confirmation that the product meets the current ETL criteria at the time of sale, so ask for it. It also says controls do not meet the criteria where individual users can change the settings in a way that undermines the saving.
How do you work out payback for your own site?
- List the fittings to change, with the watts drawn by each now and after the upgrade.
- Find the hours each group runs in a year, from the meter data or a logger on the lighting circuit.
- Multiply the watts removed by the hours, and divide by 1,000, to get kWh saved.
- Multiply by the unit rate on your bill, then divide the installed price by that yearly saving.
- Re-measure a year later. The voltage optimisation guide shows how lighting changes alter the load that other measures act on.
No source checked gives a dated price for fittings or installation, so none is given here. Readers who want help weighing lighting against other measures at a site can send an enquiry through the form on the energy management page.
What can go wrong with a lighting upgrade?
- Too little light. Regulation 8 of the Workplace (Health, Safety and Welfare) Regulations 1992 says every workplace shall have suitable and sufficient lighting. BSI's BS EN 12464-1:2021 specifies lighting requirements for most indoor workplaces in terms of quantity and quality of illumination.
- Emergency lighting overlooked. Regulation 8 requires suitable and sufficient emergency lighting where people are specially exposed to danger if the artificial lighting fails. CIBSE says emergency lighting is a legal requirement in almost all premises, and BSI notes that BS EN 12464-1 does not cover it.
- Controls that fail dark or get overridden. See the fail-safe and settings points above.
- No upkeep. CIBSE says cleaning luminaires improves their performance.
Sources and last checked
Checked on 22 October 2026. Several ranges below come from older or undated pages and are labelled as such. The official pages are the authority if they disagree with this one.
- Energy Technology List (DESNZ), Lighting (page undated), checked 22 October 2026
- Energy Technology List, Guidance Note: Lighting (17 April 2024), checked 22 October 2026
- GOV.UK, Energy Efficiency for Businesses, checked 22 October 2026
- CIBSE, CIBSE Top Tips 2: Lighting in Buildings (undated), checked 22 October 2026
- CIBSE Journal, Module 260: Retrofit or restore (January 2026), checked 22 October 2026
- CIBSE Journal, Module 41: Power quality for building electrical supplies (June 2012), checked 22 October 2026
- Carbon Trust, news release on lighting efficiency (5 December 2011) and Warehousing and logistics guide (February 2019), checked 22 October 2026
- Defra via GOV.UK, RoHS exemption applications: Secretary of State determinations, checked 22 October 2026
- legislation.gov.uk, Workplace (Health, Safety and Welfare) Regulations 1992, regulation 8, checked 22 October 2026
- BSI, BS EN 12464-1:2021 (31 August 2021) catalogue page, checked 22 October 2026
Guides on this topic
Common questions
Is emergency lighting affected by an LED upgrade?
It can be. CIBSE says emergency lighting is a legal requirement in almost all premises and should be considered as an integrated part of the building lighting. Ask how emergency units, their testing and any combined emergency fittings are handled in the quote.
Will controls work with the LED lights I already have?
The Energy Technology List says LEDs are easy to control, but it also calls controls an unlisted technology where the supplier confirms the criteria at the time of sale. Ask the controls supplier to confirm in writing that the controls suit your specific fittings.
Do lighting upgrades reduce cooling costs?
CIBSE Journal says a full lighting retrofit reduces internal heat gains while cutting lighting energy by 50 to 80 per cent. How much that eases cooling depends on the building, and the sources checked give no figure.